lohud.com

Sponsored by:

The LoHud Yankees Blog

A Yankees Blog by Journal News beat writer Peter Abraham

Yankees have no comment on Mitchell

December
13

He’s back. Howard Rubenstein had disappeared from Yankeeland in the wake of Hank Steinbrenner becoming the team spokesman/general manager.

But with the Mitchell Report out and team execs ducking for cover, Rubenstein is back with a statement on behalf of the team. Here it is:

“We are reviewing the report and have no comment.”

This entry was posted on Thursday, December 13th, 2007 at 3:39 pm by Peter Abraham.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
Share and Enjoy: del.icio.us Digg Google Technorati Yahoo! | Print This Post Print This Post | Email This Post Email This Post

121 Responses to “Yankees have no comment on Mitchell”

  1. Paulie

    Some of those players listed were Joe Torre’s boys. Maybe you should Joe T. to get his thoughts on Roger and Andy being listed as HGH users.

  2. gayle

    Thanks Howard now go back to the office and wait til George decides to speak again.Obviously Hank doesnt need you.

  3. Mike NYY- Save the Big Two

    Keep in mind Pettitte only did this for a brief time in 2002. It was not a common thing. Also, their is NO evidence of eityher actually doing it other than the word of a criminal, Radomski.

  4. Mike NYY- Save the Big Two

    The Return of a Legend

  5. ItalianGreco

    I wonder what the sux are saying about him…..

    “Lets give him a raise because he did not drop the dime on our boys”

  6. migames

    “Joe Torre’s boys”

    yes, lets throw Joe under the bus to.

  7. Mike NYY- Save the Big Two

    Was Damon on the list?

  8. Rebecca--Optimist Prime--Save the Three Musketeers!

    You would have thought the hit would have been much bigger. With the exception of Pettitte and Clemens, our biggest stars are unscathed.

  9. Ice Age

    Boston got off easy, too easy.

  10. mel

    The best thing for the Yankees to do is to never make a comment on this report.

    When asked for a comment they should say, “We have no comment at this time. Please seek out the other 29 teams listed in the report.”

  11. Viking Coach

    Congratulations to the 2000 World Champions New York Cheaters******* Igues we know why Clemens threw the bat at Piazza.. ROID RAGE !!!!!!! No Hall of Fame for Roger

  12. Bronx Bomber

    Glenallen Hill, David Justice, Chuck Knoblauch, Denny Neagle, Jose Canseco….these guys all were part of the World Series Champion 2000 Yankees.

  13. Bronx Bomber

    good to see Gagne finally exposed too.

  14. SJ44

    Damon was not in the report.

  15. james

    When did that fraud Gagne use it. during his streak or lately when he been trying to rehab his arm

  16. raymagnetic (SANTANA IS LEGEND)

    Congratulations to the 2000 World Champions New York Cheaters******* Igues we know why Clemens threw the bat at Piazza.. ROID RAGE !!!!!!! No Hall of Fame for Roger

    When trolling please try to at least write proper English.

  17. ItalianGreco

    Is a viking the same thing as a troll???

  18. Bronx Bomber

    i only mention those guys affiliation with the 2000 team b/c I don’t think Pete knows of it….since he didnt mention them.

  19. Mr. Vegas

    I see a huge internal inconsistency with Mitchell’s report. One the one hand, he acknowledges that he was only able to identify a fraction of the players who were involved with PEDs (in large part because his star witnesses happened to be associated with NY teams). On the other hand, he says it would be a mistake to keep digging until the names of ALL players involved with PEDs were known. In other words, it’s important that the names that happened to come out today (which are probably 70% Yankee-related) should be revealed, but anyone Mitchell failed to turn up should be left alone. What kind of nonsense is that?

  20. stuart

    Mitchell had 2 sources a yankee trainer and the met guy that is why more players from there teams are on the list..

    if there counterparts on the other major league teams spoke there would be more players from there teams.. I thought the list would be much more widespread and more names….very few suprises on the list….

  21. stuart

    yeah glen allen hill, canseco, and denny neagle were integral to the yanks titles.. and matt cassell has been a integral part of the patriots championships!!!!!!!

    my comment is as stupid as the troll comments….....

    mitchell had only 2 sources what a joke….2 ny guys….

  22. baseball expert

    PETTITTE IS JUST ANOTHER ROID RAGER

  23. Mike NYY- Save the Big Two

    Thanks SJ

    Just from some of what I`ve heard their doesn’t seem to be much evidence to back these things up.

    Brandon Donnelly was named because he was called “a juice guy” in an E-Mail by a Boston executive.

    Pettitte’s use is being exxagerated. He asked Radomski (or MCNamee not sure which) about HGH once and never again

  24. baseball expert

    IM SO MAD CAUSE I ALWAYS SUPPORT PETTITTE BUT I KNOW THE TRUTH! HES JUST ANOTHER ROID RAGER LIKE HIS BUDDY ROGER “ROCKET SYRINGE” CLEMENS

  25. Bronx Bomber

    all in all this is just another controversy d’jour. Andy used HGH once to rehab his elbow during a season the Yanks got bounced in the first round….yyyyyyyaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwnnn.

    When do pitchers and catchers report.

  26. DVB

    Will all the Boston Idiots please come out and play ? Oh, too late, they are already out in FULL FORCE !

  27. pat

    Mike
    Happy spin is one thing but…..
    McNamee said he injected Pettitte 2 or 4 times personally. That’s a little more than asking.

  28. Fernando Alejandro

    This report is a huge disappointment. Shocking that it was largely based on the word of a New York club house attendant. Also shocking that of the Red Sox players named there’s Mo Vaughn, someone who was widely disliked in his time with Boston, Eric Gagne (half a season) and Brendan Donnelly who was surprisingly non-tendered by Boston yesterday. There may be no bias, but its clear where the central focus was.

  29. The Dude

    Ha, I just realized that Sen. Mitchell spoke at my college commencement. I get the feeling that in a few years no one will remember today’s speech, either.

  30. baseball expert

    ortiz is being protected by mitchell. everyone knows he took roids!

  31. Doreen

    I am finding it just a bit curious that although Radomski worked for the Mets, or in the Mets clubhouse, the names associated with him have Yankees ties.

  32. TheGhostOfAlvaroEspinoza

    baseball expert, did you even read his section of the report? He took HGH like 2-4 times while on the DL once, and before it was banned. I genuinely feel bad for Andy, the media is going to drag him through the mud over this. What a farce.

  33. Clay Bellinger

    This is not a Yankees Red Sox issue. It came out that a majority of Yankees were on the list. It is what it is, people need to accept that.

  34. baseball expert

    do everyone here hate roger clemens now?

  35. mel

    OK. I just picked myself off the floor. Steve Phillips was spot on in his analysis of how GM’s will approach tainted players.

  36. raymagnetic (SANTANA IS LEGEND)

    baseball expert,

    I say this as kindly as I can, please do everyone here a favor. Why don’t you just take a long walk on a short pier, okay?

  37. mel

    No, I don’t hate Roger Clemens. I don’t even care, he’s not on the team anymore.

    Still love Andy.

  38. Clay Bellinger

    As a yankee fan I never loved roger Clemens or what came with him but I loved when he did well.

  39. Clay Bellinger

    I think you mean make like a tree and get out of here!

  40. Viking Coach

    Truth hurts, Roger is a cheater, Andy is a cheater, I don’t want to hear any more crap about how Torre’s guys are of such great charecter. Knobloch is a cheater. The Dynasty of the late 1990’s is FOREVER TARNISHED. How is that for proper english you fan of a tarnished dynasty

  41. I conducted my own report

    http://tenstarmusic.com/images/VaritekCheater.jpg

  42. baseball expert

    raymagnetic- you want me to kill myself?

  43. willis

    I just got home…fired up the blog… can someone please
    point me to a compelte list of players named?

    Just curious a co worker told me only one Sox player from either championship team was named… how can that be true??

  44. mel

    I used to dream that Roger would wear a Yankees cap in the HOF. Now? Whatever. His bust should have a cap with a rocket on it.

  45. TheGhostOfAlvaroEspinoza

    That’s why the names are so damning…if you’re name is on the report you’re going to be dragged through the mud no matter what the circumstances. No matter how flimsy the evidence is. Guess you can’t expect much from a former U.S. Senator with a supposedly glowing track record. We’ve probably detained people at Guantanamo over less.

    I’m only half joking. Man, my own bitterness surprises me.

  46. Clay Bellinger

    The yankee dynasty is tarnished? , then I guess everything in baseball is tarnished over the last 15 years, because this report is not the final tell all source on steroids.

  47. Chuck

    Please be advised that the Mitchell Report has been renamed. It shall now be referred to as “A Red Sox Christmas Present: The Anecdotal Report on Steroid Use by Present and Former Yankees and Other Bedtime Stories.”

    There are basically three sources used by Mitchell: A former Yankee pitcher, a former Yankee assistant trainer and a Mets towel boy. This report is far from comprehensive and should not have been released in the manner it was. Mitchell screwed this up badly.

  48. TheGhostOfAlvaroEspinoza

    Hey Viking, the English was fine, but your grammar and punctuation still suck.

  49. baseball expert

    I can name sox players on roids- varitek, ortiz, schilling, nixon, kapler, foulke

  50. Bob from NJ

    Spokesman/General Manager? Very clear. Just give up this pointless crusade, Cashman is obviously still in charge. It’s tired and boring.

  51. Bob from NJ

    Spokesman/General Manager? Very clever. Just give up this pointless crusade, Cashman is obviously still in charge. It’s tired and boring.

  52. Giuseppe Franco

    Viking,

    Whatever makes you feel better knowing the Red Sox will always be in the Yanks’ shadow.

    A-Rod was the biggest story after Game 4 of the World Series.

    Pathetic. The Yankees still run the baseball universe.

  53. mel

    Gammons is all indignant on the behalf of Brian Roberts.

  54. Phil

    and Brendan Donnelly.

  55. Jeeters Cheaters

    Roger Clemens: “C’mon Andy, bend over and take one for the the team”

    Andy Pettite: “Ok Rocket but don’t tell Derek or Joe”

    Roger Clemems: “Don’t worry, It’ll be our little secret kid”

    26*

  56. Chuck

    mel: Regardless of who you are a fan of, Brian Roberts—more than anyone—shouldn’t have been named. Roberts and Bigbie were roomies with Segui in 2001. Bigbie says that he and Segui used steroids but he never saw Roberts use. However, Bigbie said that in 2004 Roberts said that he used steroids “once or twice” in 2003.

    That is all the evidence against Roberts. BS.

  57. randy l.

    mel-
    it’s way to early to make judgements on roger or any player. just the fact that yankee fans feel like they need to circle the wagons makes me very skeptical of the objectivity of this report.

    the report looks like amateur hour .

  58. joe b

    It looks like a lot of Yankees, present & former mentioned. Clemens, Petit. Sheffield, Giambi, Velardi, Conseco and Knoblach. Why don’t you call Mike & dog or Micheal K. now. You never stopped complaining about Bonds while your house was tainted all the time.

  59. Mr. Vegas

    And another thing: This report is practically a parody of an embarrassing conflict of interest situation. Mitchell was hired despite being a well known fan and part-owner (I believe) of the Red Sox. Given this, the absolute worst-case scenario in terms of the integrity of the investtigation was for the report to contain a heavy emphasis on current or former Yankees players. And – surprise, surprise, surprise!—that is EXACTLY the report we got.

    Mitchell can talk all he wants about his success with the Northern Ireland peace talks, despite the alleged “conflict” of having some Irish blood in your lineage; but that doesn’t mean he didn’t have a genuine, disqualifying conflict of interest in the present case.

    BTW, George, in a negotiation setting like the Northern Ireland talks, where participation is optional, the parties can each decide whether or not to overlook your conflict of interest. If they don’t like the way the negotiations are going, as a result of your “conflict” or for any other reason, they can simply walk away. However, the players you investigated obviously had no say in whether, as a Red Sox board member, you were the right guy to be heading up the investigation.

    How stupid does this guy think we are?

  60. Clay Bellinger

    Some fans like to deny, deny, deny, just realize that ALOT of players took steroids, whether mentioned in the report or not.

  61. Fernando Alejandro

    I’m not upset about the Yanks mentioned on the report. Pettitte, Giambi, Clemens, and Sheffield have all been brought up before. What I am upset about is how well centered around New York the report is. It makes me more upset that Mitchell is linked with the Red Sox.

    I mean, the only people this guy can find to comment happen to be New York guys? This is garbage.

  62. mel

    No, I agree that Roberts case was pure hearsay. It’s just funny. Gammons did say that only 1/3 of the anecdotal stuff is credible.

  63. S.o.S.27

    Again,I hope congress steps in and disciplines(suspensions or asked to resign) Selig and Fehr for this shady so called investigation. They should be the ones to blame for allowing this steroid era to run out of control.

    Its time to clean up the game and it starts with those two jokers.

  64. Viking Coach

    Guiseppe,

    I could care less about the Red Sox. I am getting enjoyment out of the fact that all of you holier than thou Yankee Fans are trying to deflect this report. Clemens, Pettite, Giambi, Knolbloch, Stanton, Grimsley, Justice, Villone, Sheffield, GlenAllen Hill, Canseco. Guys this is not a report to protect the RedSox, stop whinning. Face facts you root for a team that has had a bunch of cheaters play for them. I hope Andy goes to confession.

  65. Andrea

    This entire report is based on hearsay. It’s kind of awful.

  66. RVA Yanks

    I loved what Clemens did for us but I love Andy for Andy because he’s a homegrown start. I forgive him 100% for using the HGH, back when it was legal. He shouldn’t have done it and there are no excuses for doing it, even injury related unless a doctor is giving it to you. Pettitte is still The Man.

    People make mistakes, you forgive them and move on. I can forgive Clemens but it’s really hard to swallow since it seemed like he was one of the hard working type and got his success from that.

    Trust me, there are a lot more Yankees and Red Sox that bought/used PEDs, they just didn’t come up. They are the lucky ones.

  67. KB

    I think Clay hit in on the head. This is not the tell-all or end point. It does drag some people’s names down but lacks evidence of substance.

    The real issue as I see it for AP is that he continues to train with a guy who uses PEDs as part of the regime. Andy may never have done them again after the injury rehab. Or he may have continued to use many times. There is no answer in the report and none coming.

    As far as the fact that all of the sources come from NY and thus it is largely ex-Yankees- who cares? If Sox want to use the fact that Kevin Brown (as a Dodger), Villone (as a Mariner), Knoblauch, Stanton, etc used steroids to make them believe that the Yanks of the early 2000s were cheaters, fine. That’s about as fair as saying that the Pats are cheaters now because harrison used HGH. Jeter, Brosius, O’ Neill, Bernie did not and were the heart of the team as Brady, Seymour, Moss, Samuel are the heart of the Pats.

  68. willis

    Viking Coach:

    You seem so excited for the chance to bash the Yankees and their fans…. typing with one hand are we?? ;)

  69. Mitchell's Eleven

    What really is damning, to me, is that MLB teams hired these dirtbags as trainers, strength coaches, etc. Wherever they went, it seemed like the drugs followed. Awful.

    So much for that early 2000s Orioles’ youth movement, eh?

    Pettitte is still the man.

  70. The Mick

    no sosa, no mcgwire, no dykstra, no brady anderson…did i leave anyone out…no credibility.

  71. vince

    Let’s talk baseball, enough of this. There won’t be any penalties, fines or suspensions anyway.
    The White Sox said they could listen to offers for first baseman Paul Konerko, who might bring the most value.
    They are looking for an outfielder. How about Matsui for Konerko?

  72. mel

    KB,

    You mean to tell me that Andy still uses this trainer?

  73. Mike R.

    Clay Bellinger
    December 13th, 2007 at 4:17 pm

    Some fans like to deny, deny, deny, just realize that ALOT of players took steroids, whether mentioned in the report or not.

    I don’t think that fans are upset because they believe the report is false. It’s more a matter of lacking due process and the shadiness of Mitchell’s known Red Sox ties and convenient lack of any current Red Sox.

  74. Gitmo

    There actually has been some good commentary on ESPN, however, one large point has NOT been discussed. How New York-centric the report is… being that the majority of players named are Yankees and Mets… ok, and Orioles. It is amazing to me how unscathed the Red Sox (and anyone west of the Hudson River) are. Shouldn’t the inherent conflict of interest due to Mitchell’s ties to the Sox be mentioned?

  75. Viking Coach

    For everybody that is stating this report is based on hearsay; I say this “get your heads out of the sand” . You poor Yankee fans are in denial. No it can’t be its a Redsox conspiracy, not my Andy, Maybe Andy pulled the hat down so far so we could’nt see how big his head beacame from the HGH. CHEATERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  76. Fernando Alejandro

    Center this report around one team, any team for any extended period of time, and you’ll find over a dozen names to throw on your report. I’m not mad that these Yankee players are on there, as I’ve said there’s been speculation around them before. It just so happens that this report is centered on the Yankees. Shocking that Mitchell would do this.

  77. RVA Yanks

    Viking Coach – It’s the fact the report is inconsistent and is essentially a witch hunt. Why is it that those select players in the Mitchell Report get names but the rest (and YES, there are a ton of other players not named today that used PEDs, EVEN IN YOUR FAVORITE CLUBHOUSE) get off?

    It’s not about if it was wrong of them to use, it’s more about how the Mitchell Report is more of a “look at us Congress, we fixed it!” half-assed $20 million job based on 2 sources. If I were any MLB fan I would be upset for the shoddy work we get after 20 months of waiting.

    Bud Selig = worst MLB commissioner ever.

  78. KB

    Mel,

    Both Clemens and Andy were quoted this past season as standing by this guy and continuing to rely on him. Its in the report and was in the NY papers sometime around May-June this summer.

  79. willis

    Viking Coach

    Which MLB team are you a fan of?

  80. S.o.S.27

    Clay-Some fans like to deny, deny, deny, just realize that ALOT of players took steroids, whether mentioned in the report or not.

    I believe what I think Schilling or Conseco said years back. 75% of players are on steroids of some form of PED.My problem with all this is all the time and riggorous investigation turned out to be nothing more than here say from 2 new york guys. The investigation was half a$$ed to say the least. You cant tell me there are isnt anyone on the Sox that didnt use it(Ortiz,Manny,Schill,Drew,Kapler,Ferritek,etc.) We should of all expected this the second Dumb(Selig) appointed Dumber(Mitchell sox employee)to do this investigation.

  81. J. V. - Yonkers

    Mitchell seems proud of his accomplishments in Northern Ireland. He can now feel proud of his accomplishments in a college cowtown 200 miles north on I-95.
    Who loves chowdah more, Mitchell or Gammons ?

  82. RVA Yanks

    HGH ≠ Steroids

  83. The Mick

    next up will be clueless bud with his long face…like he didnt know when they were raking in the bucks…kinda makes me feel for mcgwire, he was being used…now he’s the poster boy…must be really pissed now, couldn’t even make mitchells list

  84. Brian (Red Sox Fan)

    Randy 1

    (1) Let me begin by stating that I’m of the opinion that Varitek, Nixon, Kapler, Nomar and Ortiz may well have used PEDs. I’m not accusing them, but I’d be less than stunned to hear that it was the case.

    (2) It’s way too LATE to make judgments on Clemens. In his last (contract) year in Boston, he miraculously reversed a three-year decline. He continued to gain prodigious amounts of weight, weighing 50 more pounds than during his first 20 strikeout performance. He continued to pitch in a dominant fashion well into his 40s.
    Some people are being tarred on dubious “evidence,” but not Clemens. With the exception of Bonds, he has been the MOST obvious abuser. His annual “retirements” have served to give him an eight month sabattical from the mandatory testing program. It’s all ridiculously obvious.

    I’ll join with Yankee fans in defending those who have been tarnished by dubious factoids. But Yankee fans can save their own credibility by cutting Clemens loose. He duped you last year, trying to go to the Chemical Store in order to cash in on one more $20 million rodeo. Let him go.

  85. Andrea

    Viking Coach: do you realize what hearsay is? cause that’s what this is.

  86. ted

    “no sosa, no mcgwire, no dykstra, no brady anderson…did i leave anyone out…no credibility.”

    dykstra was on a complete player list that I saw, I haven’t read the report though

  87. murphydog

    Viking Coach:

    A real balanced and reasonable position, especially since none of those guys ever played for any other teams – - all lifetime Yankees. And of course they never used PEDs before the Yankees (or after). Hint: Think before you write.

  88. Mitchell's Eleven

    Mick – Dykstra’s in there.

  89. KB

    My mistake- in 2006 when issues came up involving McNamee, Clemens and Pettitte both said they had long-standing relationships with him and continue to rely on him in their training. Hopefully they’ve parted ways since then, but I think that creates a stigma that might be harder to walk away from.

  90. Christine

    baseball expert, you add nothing to the conversation. Take the other poster’s advice: take a nice long walk off a short pier.

  91. The Mick

    bud, “the integrity of the game,!!! ” lol…you knew all along…phonies

  92. willis

    Looks like this is the “list” :

    Chad Allen
    Rick Ankiel
    David Bell
    Mike Bell
    Marvin Benard
    Gary Bennett, Jr.
    Larry Bigbie
    Barry Bonds
    Kevin Brown
    Paul Byrd
    Jose Canseco
    Mark Carreon
    Jason Christiansen
    Howie Clark
    Roger Clemens
    Jack Cust
    Brendan Donnelly
    Chris Donnels
    Lenny Dykstra
    Bobby Estalella
    Matt Franco
    Ryan Franklin
    Eric Gagne
    Jason Giambi
    Jeremy Giambi
    Jay Gibbons
    Troy Glaus
    Jason Grimsley
    Jose Guillen
    Jerry Hairston, Jr.
    Matt Herges
    Phil Hiatt
    Glenallen Hill
    Darren Holmes
    Todd Hundley
    David Justice
    Chuck Knoblauch
    Tim Laker
    Mike Lansing
    Paul Lo Duca
    Exavier “Nook” Logan
    Josias Manzanillo
    Gary Matthews, Jr.
    Mark McGwire
    Cody McKay
    Kent Mercker
    Bart Miadich
    Hal Morris
    Daniel Naulty
    Denny Neagle
    Rafael Palmeiro
    Jim Parque
    Andy Pettitte
    Adam Piatt
    Todd Pratt
    Adam Riggs
    Brian Roberts
    John Rocker
    F.P. Santangelo
    Benito Santiago
    Scott Schoeneweis
    David Segui
    Gary Sheffield
    Miguel Tejada
    Ismael Valdez
    Mo Vaughn
    Randy Velarde
    Ron Villone
    Fernando Vina
    Rondell White
    Jeff Williams
    Matt Williams
    Todd Williams
    Steve Woodard
    Kevin Young
    Gregg Zaun

  93. RVA Yanks

    “I’ll join with Yankee fans in defending those who have been tarnished by dubious factoids. But Yankee fans can save their own credibility by cutting Clemens loose. He duped you last year, trying to go to the Chemical Store in order to cash in on one more $20 million rodeo. Let him go.”

    Really best thing a Red Sox fan has come in here and said. You can sit there and say there’s no hard PROOF, but they have an awful lot on Clemens in the report. All signs want to point to YES, but our heart gets in the way.

  94. The Mick

    ok thanks, mitch 11…did i leave anyone else out? luis gonzales?

  95. Viking Coach

    Willis,

    Whatever it takes, This is not a biased “Pro Red Sox Report” Lets stay focused on the issue. This report at least accuses the players of using the drugs, if thye remain silnet and offer no denial of the report that will speak volumes. The Empier has started to crumble that fact cannot be denied. The RedSox are beating you on the field, and today your tem has key members of it accused of being CHEATERS. If you think this report is all hearsay you are a little too naieve for me.

  96. Mike in SF

    Ummmmm…..

    Yay A-Rod is back!

    Let’s go get Prior!

  97. The Mick

    bud…throw away the script and speak from the heart

  98. The Mick

    what premeditated garbage…

  99. The Mick

    would you buy a used car from this man?

  100. willis

    Viking Coach

    Why can’t you just tell me who your favorite MLB team is?

  101. willis

    wow that dude can’t spell… is he 7 years old?

  102. Viking Coach

    Hey All of you in Denial Yankee Fans,

    HAPPY HOLIDAYS !!! I hope I get a size 9 Andy Pettite Yankee Hat under my Xmas tree this year. CHEATERS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  103. Fernando Alejandro

    Clemens did it. Let’s get that out of the way. Pettitte did HGH (not steroids, please don’t get it confused) before it was a banned substance. I fault him, because it is a performance enhancing substance that gives an unfair advantage.

    Now with that being said, I still think its garbage that the report is based around these two New York guys. Base it on a Mariners trainer, you’ll get a bunch of Mariners on your list. Base it on a Red Sox trainer, you’ll get a bunch of Red Sox players on your list. Mitchell bases it in New York, and got a bunch of New Yorkers on his list.

  104. stanzy

    Look, the problem here is details. Pettite used 2-4 shots of HGH to rehab his elbow—before it was banned. Did he use it after that? Did he use anything else? If not, what’s the issue? At the time, no one even looked down on HGH. They used to sell that stuff on the radio! So if his use was nothing more than that, he should not have been mentioned in the report.

    Clemens is another story. If he was using steroids regularly to boost his ability to compete, then yeah, as Dan Wetzel says, he’s as bad as Bonds and should be treated the same.

    I thought the idea of this investigation was to detail the depth and breadth of abuse of performance enhancing drugs in MLB. Instead it appears to list a small sampling of the abusers right alongside the names of people who may have gotten effectively nothing more than a contact high. It’s fine to destroy the reputations that deserve destruction—though it would be better to be thorough about it. But it’s ridiculous to destroy—by association—the reputations of people who had almost nothing to do with something that wasn’t even illegal or prohibited by the sport in the first place. I’m sure several of the names fall into this second group.

    Also, the fact that no major Red Sox players were implicated doesn’t concern me. What does concern me is that this supposedly thorough, rigorous investigation relied on so few sources, from a very limited geographic location, and leveled accusations with very little corroborating evidence. And I don’t want to hear about the canceled checks—unless they say “for performance enhancing drugs” in the memo.

    What an irresponsible thing Mitchell and Selig have done. Why am I not surprised?

  105. Bronxbyte

    Listen to America’s favorite hoot, Bud Selig. Ever the pretty picture painter. He still thinks Humpty Dumpty was pushed.
    He was such a poor speller in his Milwaukee youth that teachers made him stay after school and constantly write the word “integrity” on a chalkboard until he got it right.

  106. The Mick

    did bud just say he didnt read the report…lol

  107. Viking Coach

    Willis I am a Mets Fan, and Todd Hundley’s record for homeruns as a catcher should have an asterik next to it. He is a CHEATER. Clemens is amazing, he had to know that he would be named in the report, and he still basically stole ove 20 million from the Yankees. If you slow down the Suyzn Waldman tape you can hear her say ” Oh my Gawd, Roger is in George’s Bawx, with a syringe sticking out of his butt”

  108. The Mick

    why does bud move his lips when he listens to reporters questions?

  109. Born in da Bronx

    I would want a lot more for $20 million. In fact I probably could have written a better report for 5. He does this huge investigation and has to rely on two drug dealers for his story. For shame. For Shame. I am not defending anyone of those named but in a country that relies on due process, you cannot just take the words of a snitch without getting evidence. This report is a mockery of all we hold precious in this country. I still cannot get over the $20 million price tag for rumors and no evidence.

  110. The Mick

    fernando,

    well said…life goes on…baseball is in the moment…can’t wait for opening day!

  111. The Mick

    bud is confessing…didnt want people to say “what were they hiding?”...poor excuse and waste of money

  112. Brian (Red Sox Fan)

    Born in da Bronx

    If you had $20 million, would you spend it on:
    (A) The Mitchell Report
    (B) The 2007 Roger Clemens

    Your answer will be your total grade for the class Waste of Money 101

  113. Keith

    Gone unnnoticed with all the Mitchell buffoonery is the Twins signing SS Adam Everett which paints Boston in a corner in thinking they could dangle prospect Jed Lowrie as part of a Santana package.
    Tough break …

  114. Born in da Bronx

    Dear Brian,

    I would spend it on you so you could get a life instead of trolling a Yankee blog.

  115. sunny615

    F that – I’d keep the $20 mil and move to Aruba.

  116. Brian (Red Sox Fan)

    Born in da Bronx ….. You can pass Waste of Money 101, but you flunk Interpersonal Relations 103/\.

    Lighten up. Happy Holidays!

  117. Alan

    What a pent up bag of nothing. The Mitchell Report had as much teeth as the Lewis Libby fiasco.

  118. This just in ......

    George Mitchell arrived in snowbound Bahhstin just 15 minutes ago and is now having a bowel of chowdah with fellow Socks hoot Peter Gammons.

  119. heshel

    As a mets fan I’am just grateful for two things. One Mike Piazza wasnt on the list.Honestly that would be as crushing for us as it would for you to find out Bernie Williams was using. An second I am glad Paul Loduca is gone I could just see him pushing David wright or Reyes to use an that would be as bad as the gooden strawberry days.
    p.s I know its impossible but if Selig ever decided to give the 2000 world series to us I wouldent exactly be against it. seeing as how you had this in the mitchell report…

    “According to McNamee, during the middle of the 2000 season Clemens made it clear that he was ready to use steroids again. During the latter part of the regular season, McNamee injected Clemens in the buttocks four to six times with testosterone from a bottle labeled either Sustanon 250 or Deca-Durabolin that McNamee had obtained from Radomski.”

    2000 world series against mets:

    1-0 8ip 2h 0r 0bb 9k’s

    17 Yanks
    Jason Giambi
    Gary Sheffield
    Randy Velarde
    Hal Morris
    Rondell White
    Roger Clemens
    Andy Pettitte
    Chuck Knoblauch
    Jason Grimsley
    David Justice
    Glenallen Hill
    Denny Neagle
    Ron Villone
    Todd Williams
    Kevin Brown
    Jose Canseco
    Darren Holmes

    3 both for mets and yankees. I am not including Justice since he never played for us.
    Josias Manzanillo
    Todd Pratt
    Mike Stanton

    Only three where on the team last season Villone, Rawjah and Pettite.. not a good day to be a yankee fan. But thank the lord Mike Piazza is going into the hall of fame he will send Rawjah a post card on his induction day.

    P.P.S Can Peter get any commentary from Susan Waldmen I would very much like to see her reaction right about now.

  120. Drive 4-5

    I hate seeing Pettitte and Clemens getting burned today as much as anybody. But I don’t think we should go overboard with Mitchell conflict of interest charges. He’s a former federal judge and has been involved with peace negotiations around the world.

    His biggest mistake was that he should have permanently broken ties with the Red Sox as soon as he took on the investigation. Absent of that disassociation,he should have at least done more investigation about the Red Sox than any other team. When he didn’t even interview Canseco about his Red sox playing days, he left himself open to criticism.

  121. Born in da Bronx

    Dear Brian,

    bummer dude, I thought I had that one locked. Bronx personalities way different than those in genteel New England.

Leave a Reply

Advertisement
About this blog
Thoughts and discussion on the 26-time World Champion Yankees.

LoHud's Yankees News Page

Subscribe
LoHud Yankees Podcast | Get iTunes

Get blog updates via email:

About the author
Peter AbrahamPeter Abraham is the Yankees beat writer for The Journal News and LoHud.com. E-mail me at pabraham@lohud.com

READ MORE ABOUT PETER



MLB SALARY DATABASE
VIDEO CHAT ARCHIVE
Yankees Links
My Favorite Baseball Sites
Other Beat Writers
Other Yankees Blogs
Yankee Player Blogs
Minor League Team Blogs
Other cool sites
Other recent entries
Monthly Archives