This will be fun to watch, probably never see anything like it again. I imagine most of these guys are going to be highly motivated to impress. Baseball is a funny game, you never know what is going to happen.
Look at last night. What odds could you have gotten on Cervelli, Gardner and Posada going yard?
WTP – Wrong. Go back and read the rule. You can turn left or right as long as you return to first and make no attempt to go to second. You see it all the time.
I read the rule, did you? “Turning” or rotating in place? Sure you could get away with that… going either way. Unfortunately that has nothing to do with what we are talking about.
The “turning” being referred to is taking steps TOWARDS second base, like Posada did last night.
Stay on topic and don’t argue for no reason. There is literally no “other side” to this. Posada was out because the rule says he was out.
Crawdaddy September 7th, 2011 at 11:34 am
I feel sorry for those that have tickets to this game. Talk about being cheated and how expensive these tickets can be at Yankee Stadium.
5 of the 9 are egulars or regular-bench players. Of the other 4 – one is Montero – who can complain about that? ANd Pena – who at least was a regular-bench player in the majors last year.
What do mean no exactly? They can redeem them for another game that isn’t a permium game which isn’t bad considering they were playing the Orioles to begin with.
“The “turning” being referred to is taking steps TOWARDS second base, like Posada did last night.”
I wasn’t talking about Posada. I was talking about the rule. You are allowed to turn toward second as long as you return to first and make no attempt to go to second. And that’s true whether you happen to be standing in fair territory or foul territory when you make the turn.
Every baseball player since little league knows to not turn left past first base under any circumstances… becuase you NEVER leave ANYTHING up to the interpretation of the umpire that you can control. That this is even a topic of debate is quite frankly… scary.
By not exactly, I meant, well, “not exactly”. As I understand it field and main level seats can be redeemed for grandstand or terrace seats (with the dreaded proviso “subject to availability”), or for 50% off your purchase next year of a field or main level seat. So if you had field or main level seats, you are out quite a bit of $$ unless you stuck around to watch the game last night.
GB – I agree about the coaching situation. It just makes very little sense to me. You guys know by now how much I love the NJ Devils.. I think their system is probably one of the best because it preaches the same values from the lowest levels onward. By the time guys are at the AHL level, they’re groomed to be Devils and play the Devils system. I know the sports are entirely different, but the mantra and tone should be set in these guys early. If we want our guys to be patient at the plate and sound defensively (which, IMO, are the two most important aspects of our game) we need to have a staff that can help players get there with solid instruction.
Someone get Hank on the phone and make him put this on Cashman’s honey-do list
I don’t have a problem with Girardi, but it still doesn’t hide the fact that those with tickets today are going to be disappointed with so many substitutions with minor league players.
We’ll still beat em
I feel sorry for those that have tickets to this game. Talk about being cheated and how expensive these tickets can be at Yankee Stadium.
“I feel sorry for those that have tickets to this game. Talk about being cheated and how expensive these tickets can be at Yankee Stadium.”
What about if you bought field or main level seats to last night’s game?
It really is not that bad of a lineup. It just seems terrible compared to the Yankee regular beastly lineup.
Golson and Pena are the only 2 really weak bats in there and now that I have said that one if not both will go deep today.
They got an offer to redeem those tickets wiseguy.
Weather is one thing, how upset can you be about bad timing? Watching the Scranton Yankees play is something else entirely…
Montero is in there so I’m happy.
If I had tickets, I would be upset.
“They got an offer to redeem those tickets wiseguy.”
Well, not exactly.
Is this one likely to go off on time ?
Lineup shmineup, AJ is pitching!
The missing regulars will be available as needed.
This will be fun to watch, probably never see anything like it again. I imagine most of these guys are going to be highly motivated to impress. Baseball is a funny game, you never know what is going to happen.
Look at last night. What odds could you have gotten on Cervelli, Gardner and Posada going yard?
LMAO, 1. Burnett on mound 2. that lineup 3. terrible Baltimore…… I would be pi$$ed if i had tickets
Only the bottom 3 aren’t really major leaguers (starters). And they could still do something. These lineups once in a while are kind of fun.
WTP – Wrong. Go back and read the rule. You can turn left or right as long as you return to first and make no attempt to go to second. You see it all the time.
I read the rule, did you? “Turning” or rotating in place? Sure you could get away with that… going either way. Unfortunately that has nothing to do with what we are talking about.
The “turning” being referred to is taking steps TOWARDS second base, like Posada did last night.
Stay on topic and don’t argue for no reason. There is literally no “other side” to this. Posada was out because the rule says he was out.
Crawdaddy September 7th, 2011 at 11:34 am
I feel sorry for those that have tickets to this game. Talk about being cheated and how expensive these tickets can be at Yankee Stadium.
**********************
Hey, a Yankee game’s a Yankee game.
5 of the 9 are egulars or regular-bench players. Of the other 4 – one is Montero – who can complain about that? ANd Pena – who at least was a regular-bench player in the majors last year.
What do mean no exactly? They can redeem them for another game that isn’t a permium game which isn’t bad considering they were playing the Orioles to begin with.
Montero Day!
The best kind of day.
The top 6 of the lineup is actually fine. The bottom 3 will be the wild card.
By the way, Jim Duquette keeps saying that wasn’t a homerum for Cervelli when to me it would’ve gone out if that fan didn’t try to catch the ball.
Poor AJ.
Laird, Golson and Pena would be the problem for me if I had tickets.
“The “turning” being referred to is taking steps TOWARDS second base, like Posada did last night.”
I wasn’t talking about Posada. I was talking about the rule. You are allowed to turn toward second as long as you return to first and make no attempt to go to second. And that’s true whether you happen to be standing in fair territory or foul territory when you make the turn.
On a positive note-the lineup might force Burnett to focus better, realizing that his run spport might be less.
Erin-At least Buckner is not in at 1st!
Scranton gets to play at Yankee Stadium today. Guess everyone else is still asleep. I would be.
WYH – that’s… fine… but “making the turn” at first is a pretty widely understood concept, and doesn’t involve spinning in place.
At least Buckner could hit ML pitching.
Here’s hoping if the game is close that some key substitutions are made mid-game.
Every baseball player since little league knows to not turn left past first base under any circumstances… becuase you NEVER leave ANYTHING up to the interpretation of the umpire that you can control. That this is even a topic of debate is quite frankly… scary.
Yankee Trader September 7th, 2011 at 11:43 am
Erin-At least Buckner is not in at 1st!
*******************
“What do mean no exactly?”
By not exactly, I meant, well, “not exactly”. As I understand it field and main level seats can be redeemed for grandstand or terrace seats (with the dreaded proviso “subject to availability”), or for 50% off your purchase next year of a field or main level seat. So if you had field or main level seats, you are out quite a bit of $$ unless you stuck around to watch the game last night.
“Every baseball player since little league knows to not turn left past first base under any circumstances”
I’d say you see it at least once a game…
I’d bet this line up is still better than many major league teams.
Crawdaddy-
Bill Buckner was on the latest Curb Your Enthusiasm episode-Very funny!
Wave,
Yeah you see them make a turn but then return to the bag. Posada never got back to first before being tagged.
The rule is, if you make any move toward second you can be tagged out. Posada clearly made a move toward second.
ID is right, this is something every little leaguer is taught at the lowest level. Posada made a mistake, not the umpire
GB – I agree about the coaching situation. It just makes very little sense to me. You guys know by now how much I love the NJ Devils.. I think their system is probably one of the best because it preaches the same values from the lowest levels onward. By the time guys are at the AHL level, they’re groomed to be Devils and play the Devils system. I know the sports are entirely different, but the mantra and tone should be set in these guys early. If we want our guys to be patient at the plate and sound defensively (which, IMO, are the two most important aspects of our game) we need to have a staff that can help players get there with solid instruction.
Someone get Hank on the phone and make him put this on Cashman’s honey-do list
Classic:
BryanHoch If you were wondering what Nick Swisher’s iPod is playing: Cyndi Lauper’s “True Colors”
I’d say you see it at least once a game…
Not a chance.
girardi trying to win a ring, not make sure you guys get to see your favorites every day.
you go joe! and good call starting posada last night!
Enjoy the game civil ones. To the two jackasses and trolls….read my mind.
Montero is playing….that’s enough for me to watch. The Orioles likely wont play all their regulars either……
The only one happy about this lineup is Hughes.
New Post w/pregame notes
I don’t have a problem with Girardi, but it still doesn’t hide the fact that those with tickets today are going to be disappointed with so many substitutions with minor league players.
The only jackass here today was an old man that can’t read the rules.
Patrick-
I was just explaining the rule. Posada’s turn was too late for my tired eyes.
Swish probably still hasn’t sleep so Joe threw him another red bull and said your playing again son.